Know Thine Impact, Man
Guest Blogger and Girlie Girl Army Boy Sgt, Ari Solomon (creator of our absolute favorite candle line A Scent of Scandal) exposes NO IMPACT MAN’S impact.
I don’t know what brings you girls and boys out to the cinema — maybe it’s a good drama, maybe it’s a good laugh, maybe it’s vampires (you know who you are, Twilight whores). But for me, nothing is better than a great documentary. So last weekend a couple of my peeps and I saw NO IMPACT MAN. I was so excited because this doc is all about eco living. I was thinking maybe I could pick up a tip or two… or three or four. Not that I don’t already try to reduce my own impact, but there’s always room for improvement.
The movie opens with our No Impact Man, Colin Beavan, and his family taking stock of how much trash they make. It’s horrific. The average American creates almost 5 pounds of trash per day. That’s 1,800 pounds per year. They do pretty well at reducing this by composting and reusing (and refusing) containers and bags. Then, they trade in their MetroCards for bicycles. I get that riding your bicycle uses no electricity versus taking the subway (note: half of all the electricity produced in the US is from dirty ass coal) but most Americans live in a car culture. I thought taking the subway was already “green” so there you go.
The next thing the Beavan family does is change their diet. I thought for sure they’d go vegan, even if just for the project. I was quickly disappointed however. Don’t get me wrong, they do go vegetarian and briefly talk about the effects of animal agriculture on the environment (you won’t see any of that in AN INCONVENIENT TRUTH or THE ELEVENTH HOUR). But for the rest of the film, they feast on cheese, milk, and eggs.
This floored me. I couldn’t believe that someone who labeled himself “No Impact Man” wouldn’t have done elementary research on the issue. Dairy and eggs as an eco-conscious food choice? Nuh-uh, girrrrl. Just a quick minute surfing online would have shown Mr. Beavan that dairy is a disaster when it comes to the environment.
First of all, dairy cows, even organic ones, are not usually grass-fed. They are given feed, mostly corn and soy. The feed might be grown locally, but chances are that for dairy cows in New York, it’s grown in the Midwest, over a thousand miles away. And let’s not forget about shit. Farm runoff is massive, toxic, and horrible. It seeps into water tables and pollutes eco-systems. Finally, all ruminants (sheeps, cows, etc.) emit methane gas which is twenty times worse than CO2 in terms of climate drama.
In the film, Mr. Beavan says that he inspects the farms where his dairy products come from, and that he’s OK with the way the animals are treated. This gives me fair grounds to talk about the ethics of dairy farming. He brought it up, after all.
All dairy cows need to be pregnant in order to produce milk, just like humans. They are artificially inseminated in an area of the farm called the “rape rack“. Nice. Cows are pretty much kept in stalls during their gestation period (9 months, just like a human) and are hooked up to metal pipes that suck the milk from their udders. When they give birth, they get a whopping 24 hours with their baby. After that, their newborn is taken from them so we can take their milk. Female calves become dairy cows. Male calves are sold for veal. Yeah, you heard me, veal.
Meet your milk.
After about 4 years of this treatment, dairy cows become “spent”. In other words, they stop producing as much milk, their bodies worn out from pregnancy after pregnancy. At this point, they are sent to the slaughterhouse and become hamburger.
“OK with the way the animals are treated.” Really, Mr. Beavan? And how about all the energy and fossil fuels that are used to transport these cows to slaughter, and refrigerate their meat once they’re killed? How’s that for no impact?
Eggs are another issue. I don’t recall the Beavan family visiting an egg farm in the film, but let me say this. Terms like “free-range” and “cage-free” are not regulated by any government or private agency. A “cage-free” hen might only be let out of her cage for 15 minutes a day. “Free-range” might mean that hundreds of chickens are in huge crowded sheds with hardly anywhere to go. No cages, yes, but ranging freely, I don’t think so.
There’s also the horrifying fate of newborn male chicks. Since egg-laying hens also become “spent” after some time (they get sent to slaughter after a year or two), new chickens are hatched to replace them. Since males obviously don’t produce eggs, they’re useless to the industry and are “disposed” of. Some are simply put into plastic bags to suffocate, others get tossed in machines and are ground up alive. Then there’s the massive environmental problems of chicken feces.
A dumpster full of babies.
As the film progresses, our eco family gives up electricity and toilet paper. That’s right, they can’t give up cheese, but toilet paper, no biggie. Things wrap up with our family discussing what they’ve learned, and what they’re going to incorporate into their lives from now on. Electricity, toilet paper, and hot dogs (for Mr. Beavan’s wife) are definitely back in the picture. Biking to work sticks around.
When I got home from the theater, I went to the No Impact Man blog to see if someone, anyone brought up veganism during Mr. Beavan’s year-long sabbatical. In fact, someone had! Mr. Beavan responded that he was only buying food from within a 250-mile radius, and he couldn’t find any locally grown beans or nuts for protein. So, I went online and Googled. In 30 seconds, I found this place, a local organic farm that grows beans just outside Ithaca, NY (200 miles away). Did he just miss it? Kind of hard to believe, especially for someone who found directions online for how to construct a Nigerian double-pot refrigerator… don’t ask.
I also started thinking about the validity of being so rigid with mileage. Even if Mr. Beavan had to go 500 miles outside New York City for some food items, would that really be worse impact-wise than the methane gas, transportation, and refrigeration required for egg and dairy products? What about the feed that’s being transported to nourish the animals?
I applaud Mr. Beavan and his family for their efforts. I truly don’t mean to belittle his project or attack him, the film certainly had its eye-opening moments. But the vegan thing should have been a no-brainer.
Ari Solomon is the President and co-creator of the celebrated vegan candle line A Scent of Scandal After graduating from NYU’s Tisch School of the Arts, Ari first worked as an actor in New York and Los Angeles, and later hosted the wildly popular ARI’S HOLLYWOOD UPDATE on Miami’s Y-100FM. Now a prolific activist and writer for animal and human rights, Ari is a columnist for The Huffington Post.
COMMENTS
LEAVE A COMMENT
- September 2010
- August 2010
- July 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
I just stopped by your blog and thought I would say hello. I like your site design. Looking forward to reading more down the road.
(09.20.2009 12:31 pm)BWAHAHAHA on giving up toilet paper but not cheese. Truly, there are so many inconsistencies with this thinking, it’s hard to know where to start.
(09.20.2009 12:34 pm)[...] ***The GirlieGirl Army*** » Blog Archive » Know Thine Impact, Man girliegirlarmy.com/blog/20090920/know-thine-impact-man – view page – cached Guest Blogger and Girlie Girl Army Boy Sgt, Ari Solomon (creator of our absolute favorite candle line A Scent of Scandal®) exposes NO IMPACT MAN’S — From the page [...]
(09.20.2009 12:48 pm)Great piece! I thought about the same thing: Beavan researched every issue he could think of, finding obscure solutions, but somehow being vegan was too difficult? In New York state? People do it in Ethiopia! Dairy is just as bad for the environment as meat, one literally depends on the other. I suspect this truth was simply too inconvenient. Still, credit where credit is due: his points about reducing/eliminating trash and composting all organic waste were very well made and inspirational.
(09.20.2009 3:02 pm)You are so right. So many people who call themselves environmentalists simply refuse to look at the negative impact that their consumption of meat and dairy makes. Sure they can give up their cars and toilet paper, recycle and compost but giving up animal products is apparently just too much of a sacrifice for them. I think the starting point towards becoming an environmentalist should be going vegan.
(09.20.2009 3:29 pm)I agree it was astounding. He gave up electricity but not eggs and cheese. Can’t see the logic. Oh well, at least he was a veggie. Still a chance he’ll see the light.
(09.20.2009 3:39 pm)Wow, I find it so tragic that people who spent that much time and energy on reducing their impact on the environment couldn’t take the simplest, most profound step possible in achieving that goal. Even if it comes from your front yard, eating meat, dairy and eggs is the worst, most wasteful thing you can do for the earth. Thank you, Ari, for writing about this. Without veganism, the whole idea of that film is a joke!
(09.20.2009 5:17 pm)Thank you so much for posting this! I’ve been telling everyone that I can’t wait to see the movie.. I just ASSUMED they would go vegan….. but you know what they say about assuming…..
(09.20.2009 6:19 pm)You are right! I was so impressed when I first heard of this family effort a few years ago but could not believe it when I heard that they were consuming animal products. This really weakens the whole premise of their plan and of course the movie.
(09.20.2009 9:21 pm)Another excellent GGA piece from a critical thinker! Thank you!
(09.21.2009 1:07 am)Actually the protein requirements for humans are much less than what most people think - http://www.drmcdougall.com/misc/2007nl/apr/dairy.htm
(09.21.2009 11:43 am)Oh, please I could take one look at this schmuck and tell you he’s no eco-messiah or even a Joe Schmo having an epiphany. He’s just another bored yuppie. Don’t waste your time on the movie. Community gardeners and Queens cats with gardens (like us) have been composting forever.
(09.21.2009 11:52 am)The movie I’m sure is No Impact, indeed. ::yawn::
I literally was JUST writing a blog post of my own about the same exact thing. I haven’t seen the movie but I just read No Impact Man the book and was completely baffled about the complete ignorance when it comes to dairy. You summed up the problem perfectly. Great post!
(09.21.2009 3:11 pm)agreed. fabulous post.
(09.21.2009 4:54 pm)Great piece Ari! Thanks for putting to words what I am sure every vegan watching the movie would be thinking (I actually haven’t seen the movie yet myself). I would love to hear Beavan’s reply to your blog.
(09.22.2009 2:31 pm)Hi, aesome read. I just found your website and I am already a fan. =D
(09.23.2009 7:18 am)If you want to have a low impact this covers all the bases = saves you money, helps the environment, helps your health, makes you feel better, it’s so easy to do and it costs less than $50.00; Save money and the Earth and be clean at the same time! Add Bathroom Bidet Sprayers to all your bathrooms. I think Dr. Oz on Oprah said it best: “if you had pee or poop on your hand, you wouldn’t wipe it off with paper, would you? You’d wash it off” Available at http://www.bathroomsprayers.com with these you won’t even need toilet paper any more, just a towel to dry off! Don’t worry, you can still leave some out for guests and can even make it the soft stuff without feeling guilty. It’s cheap and can be installed without a plumber; and runs off the same water line to your toilet. You’ll probably pay for it in a few months of toilet paper savings. As for water use a drought is always a concern and must be dealt with prudently but remember the water use of industrial users far exceeds the water use of household users and in the case of toilet paper manufacture it is huge. The pollution and significant power use from that manufacturing process also contributes to global warming so switching to a hand bidet sprayer and lowering your toilet paper use is very green in multiple ways.
(09.23.2009 8:24 am)Hey there, just wanted to say that your last little bit about how going even 500 miles from your hours for vegan food would surely be better environmentally than animal products produced more closely got me to thinking about a similar argument I took part in on another site. And, to say that I agree with you! Anyway, the argument was by someone who bashed vegans and said we were hypocrites b/c not all the food we ate was local (I.E. bananas, kiwi, coffee, etc.)…and I reminded him that due to the MASSIVE amounts of water, grain, fossil fuels, etc. that were needed to sustain HIS diet, that even on my worst day, I’m still miles ahead of him on his best day. And I have to say I completely agree with the statement, “You can’t eat animal products and call yourself an environmentalist.” I know this pisses off a lot of those in the Environmentalist community, because they don’t wanna give up anything they think they have to eat…but I think it is dead-on!
(09.28.2009 4:33 pm)OOOPS that should have been, “500 miles from your HOUSE…”
(09.28.2009 4:34 pm)